Jesus Christ Came In The Flesh
75![]() | Amazon Price: $7.99 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $4.65 List Price: $14.99 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $9.08 List Price: $15.99 |
![]() | Amazon Price: $0.00 |
Jesus Christ Came In The Flesh
"Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God: And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God; and this is that spirit of anti-christ, whereof ye have heard that it should come; and even now already is it in the world." (1 John 4:2-3 KJV)
These two verses seem to make it so easy to detect false religion. If someone preaches that Jesus came to earth and lived in the same flesh that we do, then they are of God, but if they don’t, then they are the anti-christ.
But how can that be true with all these different Christian denominations; they all seem to teach that Jesus came in the flesh, yet their doctrines are so different.
Most believe in Sunday as the holy day of worship, and others believe it is Saturday, or the Sabbath.
Some believe it's wrong to accept blood transfusions while others see no problem with it.
Some say there is no eternal hell, while others say there is.
Most follow the latest fads of the world while others refuse to drive cars, use electricity and dress like it were still the 1800's.
What is the correct mode of baptism, do we sprinkle, pour or immerse; and when do we get baptized, as a baby or do we wait until we are adults.
Then there is the debate on when the rapture will occur, before, during or after the tribulation. Or is there even such a thing as the rapture?
Despite their differences, ALL these denominations confess that Jesus Christ came to earth as a baby born in a manger in Bethlehem. Yet their doctrines contradict each other so much that they cannot worship together as one body of Christ. Is the Bible perhaps wrong about this or is this the way Christianity is supposed to be?
The answer is no, the Bible is not wrong, and no, Christianity is not supposed to be separated by doctrines. There is a deeper meaning to the phrase "Jesus came in the flesh." Let’s take a closer look...
Jesus Preached What He Practiced
"The former treatise have I made, o Theopilus, of all that Jesus began both to do and teach," (Acts 1:1 KJV)
Jesus Christ came in the flesh and lived a sinless and holy life. He lived for about 30 years before He began preaching what He had lived for the past 30 years.
There is much to be said about how He lived His life. After His baptism He spent 40 days in the wilderness away from all human influence. He didn't have a home and many nights were spent on a mountain by Himself in prayer with His Father. He knew how important it was to stay in touch with God.
He wasn't afraid to help the poor and needy. He associated himself with some of the so-called worst sinners, even though He knew that He would be mocked as a result. He wasn't afraid to stand alone.
He was tempted in all points as we are tempted, yet He kept Himself pure. Thus when He began to teach, He taught others what He had lived for all of His life. He taught others how to live a pure and holy life, and repeatedly instructed people to go and sin no more.
Every Spirit
Let's look at 1 John 4:2-3 again. Notice how it says "every spirit" and not every person or every preacher. The mouth can easily confess that Jesus Christ came in the flesh, but the spirit cannot not lie. If the spirit confesses that Jesus came in the flesh the actions and teachings of that person will line up with the actions and teachings of Jesus when He walked upon this earth.
Any spirit that does not confess to this, the actions, teachings, or motives of that person will be contrary to what Jesus did and taught. We are instructed in several different passages to test the spirits to see if they are from God. We are not instructed to look at doctrines, but at the spirit behind the doctrines. Doing so will help us to spot the ravenous wolves in sheep's clothing.
CommentsLoading...
Good material,
I agree with you and SirDent here. If you don’t mind my adding some of my thoughts here, then feel welcome to deny my comments, I don’t wear my feelings on my sleeve.
First people come to Jesus Christ with a lot of baggage that has to be undone, before new things can be learned.
Second, up until recently most churches used the KJV Bible. Once newer translations came out publishers stopped updating the KJV, not to mention all the KJV only advocates. Please do not misunderstand me. I cut my teeth on the KJV and I love it and still use it, but I know people who have struggled with understanding it.
Third, for various reasons they rely upon teachers to tell them what the bible says. These teachers come from various denominational colleges. The colleges and professors range from strict conservative to liberals who don’t even believe the Bible to be the Word of God.
From these colleges come the pastors of the different denominational churches. They pass along what they learned. At some point in time many of these pastors and teachers begin studying the Word of God for themselves and divisions come about.
A Baptist may decide that he agrees with one doctrine of the Church of God but not on other doctrines or practices, so he teaches a mixture to his congregation. Now that is being repeated all over as some really study the Word and others are so shallow that they believe whatever new doctrine comes along or tickles their ears.
I’ve been a Christian by birth and a Baptist by choice. I’ve heard preachers say they’ve been preaching for 40 years and never changed their beliefs. I sincerely question if they’ve been open to learn, because I’ve adjusted my beliefs on a lot of things over the years.
One thing I know, none of us have arrived yet. None of us have a corner on the truth. We can all learn from each other if we are teachable. And we won’t know it all till God reveals it all to us on the other side.
In the mean time we need to study the Word for ourselves and be willing to change.
Sorry for getting off on that issue. You have good material here and I appreciate you. ~ eddie
Check out "Iglesia Ni Cristo" or "Church of Christ" which emerged in the Philippines, you might get some help on biblical questions...
Hey, as this passage clearly shows, believing the truth is truly important. E.g. if you do not believe that the Lord Jesus came in the flesh then that's of the spirit of the anti-Christ. We must love the truth, see 2 Thessalonians 2.
Those that believe in the trinity surely cannot believe that Jesus came in the flesh. To see what 'flesh' is, do a word study. Romans 8 is good, there's a contrast in it of the spirit and the flesh.
John 4:24 "God is spirit, and those who worship Him must worship in spirit and truth."
The Lord Jesus was born a man in the flesh and was tempted but never sinned as so sin was condemned. (This is also Romans 8)
God cannot be tempted - James 1:13
If you believe in the trinity then you cannot believe that the Lord Jesus was a man rather than God. He is the son of God.
Therefore this is a great test to show how lots of denominations do not walk in the truth.
God Bless
Hey,
Thanks for your reply. I hope you can see that we need to love the truth and be saved God's way not ours. Hence, to be sure of salvation we are to seek out the truth prayerfully from God's word rather than going to just any 'Christian' church.
Mark 16:16 'Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved, but whoever does not believe will be condemned.'
We must believe the truth and be baptized.
Also, please see Ephesians 4:4-6
Hey,
I believe that water baptism is necessary in keeping with what we see of the New Testament disciples e.g. acts 2:37-41 and the Ethiopian eunuch who was baptized by Philip in water.
John 3:5 'Jesus answered, "Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God'
I don't think 'church membership' is a bad thing as fellowship is important e.g. acts 2:42
Fellowship is involves having the same belief - 1John 1:1-3
For more on what I believe please see, prayerfully http://www.christadelphian.org.uk/wcb/index.html
There's a link "Baptism and salvation" to a section on baptism
Thank you
*Fellowship involves having the same belief - 1John 1:1-3
Hey,
That's a new way to consider been born of water for me. However it's just to me it seems ambiguous as Nicodemus I would guess wouldn't have known how much we're made of water. Also even though I do know, that idea doesn't seem to relate to a natural birth to me.
The example in Acts is of water baptism. In acts 10 the gentiles receive the Holy Spirit signifying that salvation has come to the gentiles and then Peter commands them to be baptized with water
In the passage that you referred to, at the beginning of Hebrews 6, Paul is saying that he wants to move past the basics of salvation and on to deeper things. So if anything this would imply water baptism is fundamental. If looking at the beginning of Hebrews 6 again you disagree with this, please let me know which version of the Bible your using (I've checked a few) or explain how you can take an alternate view of the passage.
Baptism and taking the bread and wine are physical but symbolize so much. You could say baptism goes right back to the crossing of the red sea - beginning of 1 Corinthians 10.
Loving God causes us to continually read His word which guides us to being more like our Lord Jesus' example. We seek out the truth and try to do Gods' will as we love Him. This comes out into our actions throughout our lives. We are saved by God's plan of salvation in the way appointed. Hence, if the Bible says that we need to be baptized to be saved, then that is how it is. This is why I'm arguing this point right now as I want everyone to be saved and glorify God.
Using Ephesians 4:4-6 again and 1 Corinthians 14:33 - 'For God is not a God of confusion but of peace'
I believe that the truth is vitally important and that there is only one way to be saved.
Thank you!
Hey,
A big reply but that shows the effort gone into it, thanks.
I’ll just point out that in my previous reply I wrote as if Paul wrote the letter to the Hebrews but he may not have.
Hebrews 5:11-14 says how those been written to need someone to teach them again the basic principles of the oracles of God whereas they should be moving on to more advanced topics.
At the beginning of Hebrews 6, the writer continues expressing his’ desire to leave the basics behind. Clearly he is not saying that these basics are not necessary as if there was no resurrection of the dead then we would be without hope. (1 Corinthians 15:12-19)
If you disagree with the above interpretation please let me know and specifics if possible.
I believe that we should live our lives striving to overcome sin and even though we fail to do so we have mercy from God if we are in Christ. Romans 6
Are you saying that you have never met anyone worthy to baptise you?
In regards to the thief on the cross, please read Romans 6:1-10. In baptism we associate ourselves with the Lord Jesus’ death on the cross so the thief who believed, repented and was baptised as he died with Jesus.
In reference to mark 16, you can’t be truly baptised without believing as for example many people experience full immersion at the swimming baths but baptism is symbolic and requires true belief.
Matthew 7:21-23 is a warning of how we need to do Gods’ will, that we can’t expect everyone who says they accept God, to be in the kingdom.
Thanks again
About Hebrews 5 and 6 I was just trying to establish that it does not say that baptism is unnecessary or unimportant.
When you say ‘otherwise forget it’ I take it you don’t mean ‘the basics’ as of course these build up into more advanced truths.
I’m not sure if your saying that most Christians you’ve met don’t try to overcome sin and think they will be saved but if so that’s why I put Romans 6 up the first time in my previous post as it refutes that idea.
However do you believe that you can overcome sin?
Here’s how I understand what we need to be doing to be saved. We are to constantly seek out the truth from Gods’ word prayerfully. When we have a basic understanding and believe the truth we are to repent of our sins and be baptized in water. Then we should consider ourselves dead to sin and alive to God in Christ Jesus. We are to strive to do our best to overcome sin and seek God’s will. However we are not to think that we can overcome sin in the sense of been blameless as far as the law is concerned – Galatians 3. There’s a lot on this in Romans as well. -- Also please read Hebrew 10. --
We are also to remember the Lord Jesus in the bread and the wine 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 (once baptised) Of course there’s a lot I’ve left out e.g. preaching
I see it that if we are in Christ living our lives to God that even though we may fail God every day, if we are repentant and striving to overcome our sinful nature then at the judgement there will be no sin to condemn us as we have been redeemed by our Lords sacrifice.
I therefore encourage you to strive to be perfect before God but not to believe that you can justify yourself before God as the just shall live by faith and we only have life in Gods’ mercy.
About the repentant thief, I was saying that as it says in Romans 6 that we are baptised into Jesus’ death then as the thief literally died with Jesus then this is like his water baptism. However maybe the new covenant wasn’t quite yet in place or maybe even the thief may have been baptised by Jesus’ disciples at an earlier time.
I wonder, do you think that anyone can baptise us (in water) or only someone who has the right beliefs?
I would like to point out so as not to mislead you that I do not believe that I have the Holy Spirit. I see this as different from the spirit of God which it must be as everyone has the Spirit of God in the sense that they’ll alive Ecclesiastes 12:7 Genesis 1:30 I believe that we are to be spiritual which comes through the reading of Gods’ word and to reflect Gods’ character and in that sense to have the spirit of God (character wise). I see it that the Holy Spirit outpouring at Pentecost which seems to be passed on by the laying on of apostles hands except Acts 10 where salvation to the gentiles is clearly shown by the giving of the Holy Spirit. I see it that this outpouring was for the advancement of the early church.
Thank you and I believe that all our beliefs should be scriptural and as such if you have any queries to the above I can search out the relevant passages.
Thanks again
Hey, I’ve been away at a Bible study weekend so sorry for the late reply.
I’m glad that you see that baptism is important it seems we just differ on whether or not it’s essential to salvation. I think your right that we should draw people to God through how we live our lives but I also see a place for active preaching as well:
Mark 16:15, Matthew 28:19-20, Romans 10:14-15 Note, God gives the growth 1 Corinthians 3:6,7
Above are some verses showing we are to preach. If we long for the Earth to be filled with the glory of God then preaching seems a natural response following the example set of the early Christians in the New Testament. (Of course we are not to be hypocritical but to live our lives to God and preach Gods’ word). Matthew 10:23 shows that it is not that times have changed so that we don’t need to preach now, as evidently the Lord Jesus has not yet returned to the Earth. (Though I pray that day be soon)
I feel that it may be a good idea to explain briefly what happens at my church as it seems it may differ from what your used to:
Generally the Christadelphian churches which we call ecclesias , as it’s not about the building but about why/how your meeting together, have these sort of weekly meetings:
On Sunday we meet together in fellowship to remember the Lord Jesus’ sacrifice and resurrection following the example of the early ecclesias. Acts 20:7 (not that it matters whether or not it’s Sunday) Also, 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 , Matthew 18:20
We meet together regularly in keeping with Hebrews 10:24-25. Also we strive for unity of faith to Gods’ praise John 17:11
Also during the breaking of bread service we praise God, in hymns for example, and pray to Him. Ephesians 5:19 We also have a brother exhort us from Gods’ word - 1 Thessalonians 5:11
On Sunday evenings a lot of ecclesias have a public lecture to preach and so we have further time around God’s word and opportunity to praise God together.
Also during the week we have a Bible class where a brother presents a Bible talk they have prepared and then we can discuss after. (Visitors are of course welcome to any of the services so that they may learn of God’s word)
It’s interesting how you see it that sins are revealed to you and then you deal with them. I agree that we may realise a sin we hadn’t before and then we should cut out the bad and replace it with good. According with how I interpret Luke 11:24 However I believe that we should be reading God’s word prayerfully and examining ourselves and through this we grow in understanding and see more how to live. Have you thought about how sin could be failing to do what’s right, not just doing what’s wrong?
I would say that we are to overcome the world, we are to recognise how we have failed God, repent and be baptised and then live our lives to God no more living in sin but to go sin no more. I believe as you seem to that we will never completely stop sinning and overcome sin in that way. The Lord Jesus was the only man to overcome sin. We are to live our lives to God to be holy unto Him, to put away the things of our old lives. In Christ I believe we are freed from sin in that ‘For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord.’ Romans 6:23 We are of course saved in God’s mercy not our own achievements, though we are still to strive to walk blamelessly.
Trying our best to overcome sin is not trying to be saved by works as we are to recognise that we can’t be saved through our own righteousness but God has provided the way of salvation in Christ and we love God and the Lord Jesus and so we strive to follow God and keep God’s judgements. The way in which I believe we ‘overcome’ is to accept God’s salvation and walk steadfastly in Christ until the Lord Jesus’ return or our death.
I disagree that faith can only come if you have the Holy Spirit:
See Acts 8:12-18, it shows this not to be the case. Also it shows how the Holy Spirit was given through the laying on of the apostle’s hands.
I can’t think of any passage to say that whoever is baptising must be a believer. I know that whoever is being baptised must know and believe the truth. (I don’t think I’ve heard of a license for baptising)
It does seem to me that baptism is essential for salvation as that is the way God has given us to come to Him.
Right from when Adam and Eve were given a covering of animal skins there seems to be animal sacrifice pointing forward to the Lord Jesus who becomes our covering when we put on Christ in baptism Galatians 3:27 ‘For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ.’ Why was Jesus baptised? Perhaps to show that we need to be also.
I will add that I do believe that those not saved have their end in death, not in a fiery under world where they are conscious and burning for ever more.
The way in which you put ‘two spirits’ makes me think that perhaps I wasn’t clear enough. I believe that whenever it says spirit in the Bible we are not to take that as always been the Holy Spirit gift as we can clearly see this to be the case when there’s reference to unclean spirits. Following along with that and my previous example I am saying that we need to be careful whether or not a passage talking about the spirit or spirit of God is referring to the Holy Spirit gift. Translation can be confusing as well with capital letters used some times and not others.
Here is a link http://www.christadelphians.com/biblebasics/0201de
(So as not to mislead I would like to make it clear that I’ve used links here and above to Christadelphian sites but not sites I have written)
As your reply was so big, if I have missed answering any questions you asked me, please feel free to let me know.
Thank you!
Hey,
What I was saying about preaching is that we are not to wait for people to come to us and ask us why we live as we do but to also actively preach just as Paul whom you mentioned went out and preached.
We do not need to keep the Sabbath, Colossians 2:16 and Romans 6:14. We are to meet regularly (Hebrews 10:24) with other believers who are faithful and we are to remember our Lord’s sacrifice in the bread and wine 1 Corinthians 11:24.
I do not say preach only on Sunday, the Christadelphians often have preaching efforts not on Sunday and then there’s individual preaching as well.
About Mark 16:17-18 I believe this is talking about the Holy Spirit gift that established the faith in Christ. I guess that you cannot perform any of these signs?
This is what I believe faith to be:
Now faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen. 2For by it the people of old received their commendation. 3By faith we understand that the universe was created by the word of God, so that what is seen was not made out of things that are visible.
In Acts 8 don’t the believers perfectly meet your definition of faith? They heard from God through Philip, their response and the apostle’s response and that we have the record seems to show that they recognised that the teaching was from God and then they acted upon the teaching in baptism.
What I mean about someone who does the act of baptising someone else is that I know it’s important that the person being baptised recognises the significance of the action and baptism is about the symbol, so does it matter who the baptiser is? I’m not saying that just anyone should go about baptising people. What I’m saying is that if someone has faith in God and wants to commit themselves to God through the act of baptism which they understand, then does it matter who they get to baptise them when they are going to be baptised in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. 1 Corinthians 1:10-17 shows that it’s not special who is baptising you. You seem to say that only certain people could baptise you but I’m not sure whether it even needs to be a believer, I think I need to search the scriptures further on this matter if I’m to get a better idea.
I’m not convinced of your explanation for the Lord Jesus’ baptism as Jesus is not a levitical priest as you have said. Hebrews 7. It’s another topic for me to consider further, though it does seem reasonable to me that Jesus got baptised to show the importance of water baptism.
God is merciful and this is clearly shown throughout the Bible. Our lives are from God, however except for Jesus, ‘all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.’ And ‘ the wages of sin is death’, we can see that our lives are a gift from God. Also God has provided a way of salvation for those who trust in Him. We are to be saved Gods’ way not ours. Therefore if God says that we need water baptism then that is the case, so the matter is whether or not the Bible tells us that we should be baptised in water.
God gives the increase 1 Corinthians 3:7. God’s plan is being worked out and the Earth will be filled with the knowledge of the glory of the LORD as the waters cover the sea!! God does use people though to show others the truth and to bring about His plan.
Someone, for example, may believe the truth and decide to get baptised but on the way to their baptism be killed. Now I’m not saying that they will not be saved. However, there does seem the possibility that as God searches the heart, Jeremiah 17:10, then maybe everyone who will be faithful to God and saved in His mercy will be baptised and those who die without baptism, God knows weren’t go to be saved anyway.
However, what is important is that if in God’s plan of salvation in the Bible it says that water baptism is necessary then we should get baptized.
I appreciate that some of what I’ve put you may agree with and I don’t want you to think that I think that you disagree with it all, however I am trying to be clear.
I am confused how you believe that someone gets baptised in the Holy Spirit and I wonder what makes you think that you have the Holy Spirit. I submit to God and worship Him but do not believe that I have the Holy Spirit like Peter and Paul had. Also many ‘Christians’ claim to possess the Holy Spirit but their teachings contradict and clearly, going along with Ephesians 4 and that God is not a God of confusion, then they can’t all have been shown their doctrine from the Holy Spirit. Also for example it can’t be that the hope of salvation is in eternal life in heaven and also in eternal life on Earth. (I believe God’s kingdom will be on Earth). Please can you explain how you believe you become baptised with the Holy Spirit and how you that you could know that you have the Holy Spirit.
Thank you!
Ps. I plan to try and make it clearer on what I believe about overcoming sin in another post shortly.
Hey, thanks for your reply.
I too believe that we should be able to explain our beliefs and explain them from the Bible with which I guess you also agree.
Please would you explain what you said - “The Israelites celebrated many Sabbath days, which had nothing to do with the seventh day Sabbath.”
In Acts 15 – particularly verses 19-21 and 28-29 it seems to me that we don’t need to keep the Sabbath. Colossians 2 seems to me to be saying we don’t need to keep any special days and about food or drink it seems to me that Paul is talking about food offered to idols (1 Corinthians 8) or unclean food. I don’t see myself as under the law Romans 6:14 and Galatians 2 from verse 11 and Galatians 3 but see keeping the Sabbath as part of the law.
In regards to Mark 16:17-18 I like your idea of the signs having physical and spiritual applications as it seems to be in scripture that some things have the two applications, like the Lord Jesus’ healings seem to. I believe these signs are part of the Holy Spirit gift that was around at the time of the early Christians. That in terms of miracles like drinking poison and speaking in tongues like at the beginning of Acts where people of other languages understood the disciples, I believe these are Holy Spirit gifts but that at the moment these gift are not available as the faith was established and the Bible completed. I haven’t really considered a spiritual application to the verses.
I am sorry to hear about your illness. It is true how natural things are wonderful as God created them. Even if it is not Gods’ will that you be healed in this present time, if you be in Gods’ kingdom you will have no infirmities!
In Acts 8 I would say that God revealed the faith to them through Philip.
Now we seem to have 3 main disagreements, water baptism, in regards to the Holy Spirit, and overcoming sin. I propose that we try to mainly stick to these areas? To start as I have said I plan to post on overcoming sin, perhaps we could start with this topic.
Thank you
I would like to just add that although I do not believe that we have the Holy Spirit gifts, God still guides us and listens to our prayers of faith.
'the prayer of faith will save the one who is sick'
'The prayer of a righteous person has great power as it is working.'
I believe that once we are baptised we are to consider ourselves dead to sin and not under the law - Romans 6. We are not justified by works of the law but by faith in Jesus Christ - Galatians 2:16. However, this does not mean we are to go around sinning with the attitude that we can do what we want because we have forgiveness – also Romans 6 and the end of Galatians 2. Indeed, if we love God then we do not want to sin but to do Gods’ will.
Now Romans 7 (toward the end) – ‘For I have the desire to do what is right, but not the ability to carry it out.’ And ‘So then, I myself serve the law of God with my mind, but with my flesh I serve the law of sin.’ I've picked out a couple of verses to show that we don’t need to get to a state where we no longer ever commits sins that we are aware of, to be saved. (Though, as above we are not to intentionally sin but to live our lives to God) We are to live according to the spirit – Romans 8 – “Who shall bring any charge against God’s elect? It is God who justifies. 34 Who is to condemn? Christ Jesus is the one who died—more than that, who was raised— who is at the right hand of God, who indeed is interceding for us” – end of Romans 8 –
Galatians 5 - 4 You are severed from Christ, you who would be justified by the law; you have fallen away from grace.5For through the Spirit, by faith, we ourselves eagerly wait for the hope of righteousness. 6For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision counts for anything, but only faith working through love.
13For you were called to freedom, brothers. Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another.
We are saved through faith not works, we have mercy from God in Christ Jesus. This is not an excuse to walk in sin but we are to live our lives to God, remaining in the Lord Jesus. (Our faith should be active along with works and our faith should be completed by works – James 2) As in Hebrews 4:14-16 we can pray to God for forgiveness so it is not that we stop sinning but that we receive mercy.
We are to walk in the spirit, not gratify the desires of the flesh, this link may be useful - http://www.cbm.org.uk/cbm40lesson36.pdf
Just to be ultra-clear, I do not in any way want to discourage you from trying to do what is right however we are not to try and justify ourselves through our works. We are to recognise that it is God who justifies us.
We look forward to a time when we will not sin, in God’s kingdom - 1 Corinthians 15
Thank you
OK, thanks
Thank you for this, I'm planning on carefully looking through it, unfortunately uni's keeping me really busy.
I want to just point out now Romans 14, particularly verse 5 which seems to me to clearly show that we need not keep the Sabbath. Though, it also seems to show that it is alright to keep the Sabbath in honor of the Lord. We 'should be fully convinced in (our) own mind' The last verse shows it's important to act from faith. There's also Galatians 4:10 to consider, it's important to remember we're justified by faith in Jesus Christ, not through works of the law.
I'm planning to let you know some of my thoughts on what you've put when I've looked more carefully at it.
Thanks again,
Luke
I will also leave you with a link http://www.thisisyourbible.com/media.asp?id=176
As the sections 'Modern Attitudes' and 'Seventh day Adventists' seem to be applicable to what you have said and 2 Corinthians 3 is referenced which I'd like to point out as you said about the 10 commandments been on stone.
Hey,
Yeah we agree that we should keep our consciences clean, (Though I do believe that there's more to salvation than just a clean conscience)
Yeah there does seem to be Sabbaths that aren’t the seventh day Sabbath, in the law. I’ll just point out that in Chronicles 2:4 I’m not sure the word ordinance is in the Hebrew.
In regards to Matthew 5, I do not believe that I am under the law (Romans 6), there is also the question, in context with Matthew 5 as to whether or not all has been fulfilled. Your explanation surely requires you to keep all of the law. This is in conflict with Galatians 3 particularly verse 12.
I haven’t yet looked properly at your reply about overcoming sin that mentions Sundays. However I believe that believers are meant to meet often and that it doesn’t matter what day you may happen to meet on and that there is nothing wrong with regularly meeting on Sunday.
If you believe that you need to get to a state where you no longer sin consciously, (transgressing the law included) then surely you believe you need to justify yourself, which is in conflict with Romans 3:26 that God justifies.
I haven’ t read this but I’m posting it in case you’re interested as it’s a debate on whether or not we need to keep the Sabbath - http://www.wrestedscriptures.com/sabbath/sabbath.h
Thank you,
I plan to look through your reply on ‘being justified’ more carefully later.
Hey, just a short answer to address some points from your latest reply, though I am still planning on having another look at your other reply that I mentioned in my previous post.
I believe that we are to be baptized because I believe that is what the Bible tells us we are to do. I also believe we should be baptized only if it is our decision to do so (and that it is not against our conscience). I see it as committing your life to God, which is a personal decision.
About the word ordinance not been in the original text, I want to just clarify that I wasn't arguing a point but just pointing it out.
Matthew 5:18 seems to me to be saying that as long as Heaven and Earth do not pass away then nothing will pass from the law unless all is fulfilled. I'm not saying that all has been fulfilled, I haven't really looked into it, but it does seem a possibility that all has been fulfilled, in terms of the context defining 'all'. However as I believe I'm not under the law, therefore I don't see a need to keep it, for instance, I don't observe the feasts.
I plan on getting back to you soon. On Wednesday I'm hoping to give a fuller reply.
Can you just clarify some things for me. This is from an earlier post of yours "If I do not overcome my sins, I will die the second death, and so will everyone else who does not overcome sin." This is from a more recent post of yours "sins that we know to be sins have to be overcome and eliminated from our lives." This seems to me the idea of been justified in regards to the law, so now maybe you can see what I'm getting at. Do you believe that you need to get to a state where you do not consciously sin (through the power of the Holy Spirit as you put it) to be saved? Also do you believe that the Holy Spirit will force you to no longer sin (if you ever overcome your conscious sins, as you put it) or do you believe that it will partly be your achievement. I believe that those who live forever in God's kingdom will no longer be capable of sin which is a wonderful hope. I take it that possibly you, in some way have this idea for life at present but I do not understand exactly what you believe.
Thank you!
and I'm glad that you like the link.
(P.s. Of course none of what I put is meant in an offensive way, I am trying to understand what you believe and to put my beliefs across. As we disagree there are points that I'm trying to get you to see due to their importance.)
Yes it is possible for God to have used Phillip without Philip having the Holy Spirit.
I don’t see Deuteronomy 28:58-60 as applying to me. As in I don't think I need to be careful to do all the works of that law.
I see the 10 commandments as part of the law along with the ceremonial requirements. Look at 2 Corinthians 3:6-7. Also you say that the 10 commandments are part of the law. In Romans it speaks of the law. E.g. “since you are not under law but under grace”
I believe in the power of the Holy Spirit, but not that it is given out now like in Acts. In Acts we read of two ‘outpourings’ of the Holy Spirit, the disciples at Pentecost and the gentiles with Cornelius – please see Acts 15:8. Other than that the Holy Spirit is given through the laying on of the Apostles hands if I have this right. So who is there to give the Holy Spirit through the laying on of hands now?
Through the power of the Holy Spirit, Mary gave birth –Luke 1:35 Then when the Lord Jesus was about 30 the Holy Spirit descended on him. – Luke 3:22-23 This fits in with the start of his ministry and how Jesus was then lead out to the wilderness where he was tempted. After receiving the Holy Spirit with the associated power it makes sense that there would be great temptation, but he was lead to the wilderness which seems a fitting place away from other temptations or distractions. So it seems, can you show otherwise? that Jesus had the Holy Spirit from about 30 but nevertheless never sinned.
Matthew 16:17 does not say that the Holy Spirit revealed it to Peter and this was before Pentecost. (I’m trying to show that we don’t need to have the Holy Spirit like we read of in Acts) In a way we do believe through the Holy Spirit as the Holy Spirit is identified with God’s power. As the Bible came through God’s power, in a way it came through the Holy Spirit. As we have the complete Bible now, we have no need of having the Holy Spirit within to lead us, this is how I see it.
I don’t see how not following our conscience is unknown sin. We know we are to keep a clean conscience and to repent of any sins we realize.
I don’t see why we would all have a different path to follow and different commandments. Matthew 7-13 This verse causes me to think of all those heading towards God’s kingdom on a narrow path. Of course to an extent all our lives are different. However there is only one way to be saved. God’s way. Acts 4:12.
Situations where there’s need of more than a clear conscience to be saved: What about someone that believes in a false god but maintains a clear conscience. What about 2 Thessalonians 2:10, someone who refuses to love the truth, they could still maintain a clear conscience I would think. What about if the Bible says that we are to be baptised but someone is not, they think to keep a clear conscience instead. Maybe you can say that there conscience is not clear before the true God. However, it seems to me that this doesn’t mean that they don’t see themselves as maintaining a clear conscience or that they are bothered by their conscience.
Please see 1 Peter 3:18-22, noting in particular verse 21.
About how I believe we are to live. I see it that when we are baptised into Christ that we are to live our lives by faith to God through love. I don’t it see that we are under the law so I see it that we don’t need to keep the Sabbath or feasts. According to the beginning of Romans 8, I believe we are to live according to the spirit - Galatians 5:19-23. We should express our faith through works which surely naturally follow from our love for God. We should read God’s word to guide our lives and to help us please God. However, I believe that in Christ we are forgiven our sins, so that no sin is held against us so that if we see we are going against God’s will we are to repent and believe in God’s mercy and we have forgiveness. 1John 1:7-10
I've written quite a bit and it's late here, and I have work for tomorrow so it seems good to leave it here for now.
Thanks
A little more, about 1 John 3:9
First, I'll just clarify that when I've been talking about not needing to get to a state of no longer consciously sinning that I've been talking about you may always know that you sin, (consciously aware that you sin). Rather than intentionally sinning or consciously choosing to sin which would be another topic.
So, I believe that we don't need to get to a state where we never think, "I'm sorry I did that". We may see ourselves failing every day for the rest of our lives but what is important is that we are in Christ trying to do the right thing, repentant of our failings, recognizing God's mercy.
Sorry if there's been any confusion regarding the above.
About 1 John, your explanation (getting to a state where you are perfect in respect to sins that you are aware of) doesn't make sense as it says 'sin' which is general, 'not specific sins' or 'sins that you are aware of'. Also if you got to a state where you go for a while without committing a sin that you are aware of, that doesn't mean you cannot sin.
I would think that God's seed is the Lord Jesus , "John 17:23"
Though looking at Luke 8:11, perhaps it is the word of God. Have you any passages for saying that it's the Holy Spirit?
I will also clarify that having the Holy Spirit does not mean that you cannot sin. (beginning of Luke 4) Here Jesus has the Holy Spirit but is tempted which shows that he could have sinned, though of course he never did.
It seems to me that it must be saying (in John) that those born of God cannot sin, they are not allowed to sin, they have to live their lives righteously. So someone may think that they can go on sinning and be saved but he's saying they are not allowed to, but you have to try to no longer sin, not that for those born of God, sin is impossible. This explanation seems to fit in with the context.
Alternatively he may be saying that those redeemed in the Lord Jesus Christ are forgiveness all their sins so that as long as they are truly in Christ and remain that way, then no sin is held against them so in that way they cannot sin. Any other way of interpreting the verse?
If I've misinterpreted your view please let me know.
I wrote most the above before seeing your latest replies so here's a bit more:
God can give the Holy Spirit to people but we can use the Bible to see how God works. The suggestion is that there were the two specific outpourings but other than that the Holy Spirit was passed on by the laying on of the apostles hands which would mean that around the time of the completed Bible there would no longer be loads of disciples with the Holy Spirit. Acts 2:39 For the promise is unto you, and to your children. this may be a reference to a short term outpouring. The early Christians were under the guidance of the Holy Spirit in accordance with John 14:26 - Now the Bible is complete.
How do you know that sin can only be overcome with the Holy Spirit?
Jesus would have seen who he was through the Scriptures, also I would think Mary would have said things. It makes sense that God would want Jesus to know who he is so it would be revealed to him. Isaiah 50:4
Jesus was born through the power of the Holy Spirit, that does not mean he had it from birth. I'm happy for you to prove that he already had the Holy Spirit, maybe from the old testament? However it doesn't seem that way. Also perhaps he didn't have the Holy Spirit to show us that God hasn't made it impossible for man to not sin, it is our own failing. (We know that Jesus was the only one to never sin)
Jesus overcame sin partly by filling himself with the word of God from the old testament.
There is more to reading the Bible than just reading it as a textbook. It's about your attitude as well and we should be prayerful. (Also we need to love)
We may all be in different stages with respect to the truth but I'm going to say that that doesn't mean we can ignore parts of Scripture or be saved our own way.
In Romans 14 and 1 Corinthians 8 the one described as weak is the one, if either, trying to follow the law.
Have you considered Hebrews 7:18. Do you believe that the 10 commandments are the only part of the law to be followed?
Why should you think that everyone has the Holy Spirit at some point, what about babies that die young or what about all the signs of the Holy Spirit seen in the new testament which are now absent as far as I know.
Why should baptism require such a hard condition as needing to find someone who has overcome sin. Even if you don't believe that Jesus is the only one to have overcome sin you still seem to see it as only a few have. Water baptism is a simple act so that it is so widely available.
In Luke 3:16 John shows that Jesus who is coming is superior to John. This prophecy of baptising with the Holy Spirit and with fire was fulfilled at Pentecost.
The one baptism Ephesians 4:5 is being baptised into the Lord Jesus.
In 1 Peter 3:21 it doesn't make sense to me that being baptised in the Holy Spirit would remove dirt from you. That is the outward appearance of being baptised in water. Also Noah's ark clearly corresponds to being baptised in water. The ark on the sea, surrounded by rain.
We live by the spirit by walking in love, joy .. Gal 5:22/23 We walk alive in Christ following the Bible praying for guidance...
The works we show are works following from our love for God and trying to obey Him. For example charity (with the right motives as a cheerful giver).
Have you ever performed any of the signs in Mark 16:17-18 or seen anyone perform any of them? It doesn't say that if you don't perform any signs then you don't believe.
Yeah keeping commandments is a way of showing 'works', that doesn't mean we need to keep the whole law in the old testament.
Do you believe that people who deny God all their lives, (dying in that state) may be saved?
For 2 John 1:6 see 1 John 2:7-8 There is nothing to say that the word which they’d heard was the 10 commandments. And 2 Corinthians 3:7 what about this?
We are to follow the Lord Jesus’s commandments but where does he command us to follow the 10 commandments? How we are to live our lives is outlined in the Bible, a huge topic. I’m trying to get across that we are not under the old law in Christ and that it is not that we will not be saved if we don’t become perfect in never doing wrong. Though we should aim for perfection.
I do believe that we can pray for help in overcoming sin but not that it would mean we would then be incapable of sin.
Thank you
I have just read Acts 15 and would like to point out verses 10-11. It does not say they couldn't bear the yoke until they had the Holy Spirit. Also they know that gentiles have received the Holy Spirit and you would take it (I think) that all the gentile believers definitely have the Holy Spirit - but still the comment about the yoke.
Also there's the end of verse 5 and then 28-29. If they should have kept the Sabbath but weren't aware then surely here they would have been made aware.
Thanks
(Of course I don't want you to go against your conscience but if in your study you were to see that we don't need to keep the Sabbath or that we should be baptised then you can follow your conscience and also do so.)
Reply to your response to the article on spirits
If you believe that people did not have access to the Holy Spirit continuously in the Old Testament times, but that they do now. How are the people of the Old Testament times saved, as you say that someone needs to get to a form of perfection only possible if they have the Holy Spirit?
I do not deny the power of godliness or the power of the Holy Spirit.
I believe that the Bible contains all that we need to live by. I don’t see any words of the Lord Jesus in John showing this to be false and yes Jesus said those things before the Bible was completed. You could also note that in John 14:26, it talks about remembrance which applies to the disciples not us.
Romans 10:17 “So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ.” There is nothing to say that we need to possess more than just the Bible to obtain faith. This doesn't mean that faith isn’t from God.
I have peace about what I believe and it makes sense to me but that does not mean that I have the Holy Spirit in me like the disciples at Pentecost. I’m not saying that you do this but there seem to be people who believe they have the Holy Spirit guiding them from within and as a result, wander away from the truth. God’s word is true.
Yes I believe as well that the only errors that may be in the Bible must be a result of the fact our Bibles are copies of copies of… a result of transcription and translation. Also, God has preserved His word down through the ages, so any errors are ‘minor’. The Dead Sea Scrolls are an example of how well preserved the Bible is.
The Bible is the word of God and there is no other book given us from God. If this is wrong let me know. The words of Jesus are recorded in the Bible and there is no contradiction between Jesus's sayings and the Bible. God spoke to Paul through Jesus at the road to Damascus and it’s clear that Jesus spoke to the disciples. God also speaks to us through Jesus when we read the words of Jesus. I don’t see any contradiction.
God does teach us. He teaches us through His word (amongst other ways, e.g. Hebrews 12:6,7)
The Holy Spirit been given to people, has been used for specific purposes. That does not mean that the person then lost the Holy Spirit. I see no reason to think that the gentiles in Acts 10 had the Holy Spirit taken away after it was clear that the gentiles have salvation in Jesus. Nor do I need to say that the Spirit left Jesus. Also if God were to bless someone with the use of His Holy Spirit for a short period, surely that is a good thing for them. I will also point out King Saul who perhaps had the Holy Spirit for a while but lost it due to not being fully faithful to God.
From what I’ve already said I think it should be clear that we cannot live in sin. Our lives should be dedicated to doing God’s will, persevering in the truth.
Here is a chapter (of a book that a Christadelphian has written on the Holy Spirit), which covers the Holy Spirit been given for specific purposes. The section starts with the heading ‘The Holy Spirit Gift’. http://www.antipas.org/books/holy_spirit_pearce/hs
For Galatians 5:16 see verses 22,23. There’s the spirit and the flesh opposed to each other. We are to walk by the spirit, to be spiritual, to show love, mercy… We are to change our thoughts and lives around to display God’s characteristics.
Thank you!
So we agree that we are to live our lives to God and we agree that we do not have to keep all the law e.g. the Sabbath. However, you believe that to be saved you need to reach a state of perfection, with help from God’s Holy Spirit, where you are no longer aware of any sins that you are committing, so that you only sin unknowingly. (At least this is what I think you believe)
As someone may sin and then not for a minute and then sin again then this ‘perfection’ implies that someone needs to get to a state where they can never sin again in such away that they are aware of it? However, I believe that we have forgiveness for our sins in the Lord Jesus and that we are sanctified through faith in Jesus as the Bible says and that this means that we don’t need to perfect so long as we are repentant for our failings and trying to be perfect, not so that we may be righteous of ourselves but knowing that we have life in God’s mercy.
Hebrews 10:14 I see it that our salvation is not based on the Lord Jesus’ sacrifice and our achieving perfection with the help of the Holy Spirit but purely through the Lord’s sacrifice. Hebrews 10:26 We cannot go on sinning deliberately but that is not to say that we will not be forgiven sins that aren’t deliberate but that we are aware of. Romans 7:24-25 Paul after saying that he has been delivered still says “I myself serve the law of God with my mind, but with my flesh I serve the law of sin.” I see it that we can only be perfected after the return of the Lord Jesus 1 Corinthians 15:35-58 This is the time I look forward to that in God’s mercy I may be in His kingdom and fully show forth His Glory. So then I see it that we do not need to reach a state of perfection in terms of our carrying out God’s will fully, as we are perfected in Christ, our sins are forgiven us so we still have salvation when we do miss our aim of living perfectly.
I believe that we should live every day to God so that we don’t have a specific day of worship. I’m not saying that you can’t set apart a day to God but that I don’t have Sunday as a specific day of worship.
Now as Jesus had the Holy Spirit and yet was tempted it is evident that having the Holy Spirit does not mean that you cannot sin. If Jesus could not sin because he had the Holy Spirit then he could not have been tempted. Yet we know that he was tempted.
In accordance with Acts 17:11 and knowing that verses can be quoted out of context I think it is important for us to search the Scripture. I don’t think that that means that I can’t quote a specific passage or refer to a specific verse. Looking at the whole of Acts 2 I stand by what I said that it Could be a reference to the Holy Spirit gift been given to believers for a couple of generations. Verse 38 also shows that been baptised is different to receiving the gift of the Holy Spirit. Peter quotes Joel 2. Looking at Joel 2:26-28 it seems to me that the Holy Spirit gift outpouring in Acts is only a partial fulfilment of the prophecy and that it will be completely fulfilled in a day to come.
Looking at Hebrews 11 we can see that by faith the people of old received their commendation. We know that King David for example failed to keep the 10 commandments, yet he will be in God’s kingdom I believe, Hebrews 11:39-40
God has given us freewill so that we have the choice to follow Him and be saved or to go along the broad way that leads to destruction.
In regards to 1 Corinthians 5 I believe that you could remove the brother in love. In love for God so that the man may repent and glorify God and also loving the man that he may be saved. (end of verse 5) What is love? 1 John 4:10 :)
It seems to me that Jesus overcame sin as he was the son of God and had the characteristics of his Father as we seem to of ours. He also engrossed his life in God’s word and prayer. In Luke 4 he overcame temptation with passages from the Bible. Please note Luke 2:52 I see it that Jesus had a great victory over sin by never sinning though he came in the flesh and was tempted.
Romans 14:2 I was referring to the one who abstains from meat would be the one if either who is acting in accordance with what the law says. 1 Corinthians 8:7
One needs to be careful about saying Jesus is the word of God. He is not literally the words in the Bible for instance. He is the word become flesh.
Exodus 34:5-8 is perhaps a good place to start to see God’s characteristics. Not that I’m saying that we are to judge. (Though there is a sense in which believers maybe are required to judge, like in 1 Corinthians 5 and perhaps in a future time)
I’m wasn’t saying that the Holy Spirit causes people to wander away from the truth but people who falsely believe that they have it guiding them from within. As it seems there are opposing doctrines from people who say their teachings come from them having the Holy Spirit, it seems clear that there are people that think wrongly that they have the Holy Spirit. If someone thinks they might have the Holy Spirit gift I would think that if they have it then they would know for definite, in response to my own question on how someone could know if they have the Holy Spirit gift. It seems to me that no more signs are done by believers having the Holy Spirit gift, why is this?
What do you make of Hebrews 6:4-8, Ephesians 4:30 and separately my reply on 1 Peter 3:21?
Thanks
Hey!
1 Peter 3:21, "Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, NOT as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ"
In Acts 2:38 "Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins"
Surely this shows that your view on this verse is wrong. Isn't Peter contrasting the physical with the literal saying how baptism is not about washing your body but has a spiritual meaning?
In regards to 'commandments from the beginning' 1 John 2:7-8
In regards to which commandments we should keep. We should keep ALL of God's commands to US and this includes all of the Lord Jesus' commandments to us.
1 Corinthians 7:19 We agree that we are not under the law. We are not commanded to keep all the commandments the Israelites were to keep. Abraham had the covenant of circumcision but we don't - Gal 5:2
In Romans 7:25 - "but with my flesh I serve the law of sin" Paul set his mind on the things of the spirit but there is still this but. How do you answer specifically this phrase? I've said how we are to NOT sin but I trust in God's mercy for when I do fail in my attempts at walking uprightly.
Been tempted shows the possibility to sin for if you could not sin then you could not be tempted.
I was not refuting your idea on love, I posted before you put up that verse on love.
As you believe that you need to get to a state where you are perfect in regards to sins that you are aware of and also as you freely confessed that at the moment you have too much sin in your life i.e. your not yet perfect.
How can you get to the state of perfection, by what means, what are your plans and efforts?
Thank you, I hope you had an uplifting weekend!
I believe your beliefs should be consistent with the whole Bible which has a consistent message. Verses should also be read in context and to help to understand them it can be good practice to compare them to other passages. However, I still use verses to make a point which you do as well from what I’ve seen.
Why get baptised in water if it has no meaning or point?
In reference to Noah, Peter is saying how they were saved by water. Peter is not referring to Noah been saved by faith from baptism in the Holy Spirit, that is not what it says.
In response to your response on the filth of the flesh, I thought you believed that someone could get the Holy Spirit and then get to a state of perfection? Also, 1 Colossians 1:14 - Psalm 103:12
Also don’t you think it’s your duty to search the scriptures and find out how to live rather than waiting for sins to be revealed.
I think that I have already made it clear that it is not OK to walk after the flesh, I’m trying to show that we are not saved by been perfect, we have all failed to be perfect but our redemption is in the Lord Jesus who did live a perfect life.
You say that you are waiting for the Holy Spirit to lead you to perfection but you also say that you do not have the Holy Spirit because you are not perfect?
How we are to live our lives is a massive topic but here is what someone has produced showing how we are to live according to the Bible, http://www.christadelphia.org/command.htm
Thanks
Hi,
You’ve said, “I never said water baptism has no meaning to it. It has its place when done correctly.”
Please can you explain your view on this further?
In regards to the reference to Noah in 1 Peter 3, Peter is referencing the fact that they “were brought safely through water”. He does not explicitly mention Noah’s faith or obedience. I am looking at verse 21 in the context of the previous verses.
I believe that God guides us without us needing to have the Holy Spirit gift. However, I believe the Bible still has all that we need to live by if we live prayerfully by faith and love. 2Timothy 3:16-17 The Bible shows us how our bodies are a gift from God and how we should worship God with them. Therefore we should not abuse our bodies with drugs/smoking. We’re all called to serve one another and to preach. About where we might go in our lives, we can pray for guidance and make our decisions prayerfully based on what we read in the Bible.
You’ve said “The Holy Spirit can work with you if you are living in sin” (to get to a perfect state). This view implies to me that either you need to try really hard to perfect yourself working with the Holy Spirit which would be trying to justify yourself by works, not being justified by faith. Or you will only be perfected if you are led into that state by the Holy Spirit (along with your cooperation) should that one day happen, which means that you don’t have freewill to choose but just wait in hope.
We’ve already agreed that we don’t need to keep the Sabbath. The Lord Jesus led a life perfect in regards to the law so that we don’t have to. We are saved in Gods’ mercy through faith.
Thank you
http://www.thisisyourbible.com/media.asp?id=32#a15
Good article with reference to things we've been discussing
Hi,
About water baptism you said “it serves a purpose in making a commitment to God and by witnessing to others around.” Don’t you believe that you can be baptised in the Holy Spirit, surely that would mean that your life is committed to God, therefore does that mean you believe that baptism is only to witness to those around you?
We know that Noah was saved through his faith expressed in building the ark. In 1 Peter 3, I’m looking at what Peter is talking about, not Noah's faith which is a related subject. Also water baptism does fit in with the rest of the Bible. E.g. Noah, Moses, The Lord Jesus’ baptism. The Bible talks of baptism referring to water baptism, it doesn’t say ‘water baptism’ anywhere, I am quite sure. There may be only one case where been baptised in the Holy Spirit instead of water is talked of. That is when Jesus tells the disciples that they will be baptised with the Holy Spirit. You can see that Jesus is talking to them. Like in Acts 1:5. You could maybe say that been baptised with the Holy Spirit is also implicitly mentioned in Acts 10:47
I’m not saying that water baptism ALONE will save people. However, we can see in the Bible how important baptism is.
Acts 17:26 - Psalm 34:7 – James 5:16 – Psalm 37:23 – Psalm 119:105 “Your (God’s) word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path.” God guides us and He uses His Bible to guide us. The Bible is God’s message to us, it’s His word to us, we need to be careful not to underestimate it. Jeremiah 17:10 God searches the heart, we can trust in God’s saving wisdom.
Ephesians 2:8-9 I see it that works are an outworking of faith. Where does the Bible say we must get to a state where we are never aware that we fail God to be saved, and that this can only be achieved by having the Holy Spirit gift?
In Acts 1:16 while the disciples were waiting for the Holy Spirit they acted upon what they had read in Scripture. I’m not saying we shouldn’t wait upon the Lord. Waiting upon the Lord involves living your life to God. If you’re not trying to obtain the Holy Spirit gift by works then when will it come to you? Why do you think you’ve had it and then it left, this doesn’t seem to be the experience of those in Acts, and if you’ve had the Holy Spirit then why didn’t you reach that state of perfection, which isn’t perfection as you believe you can still sin unknowingly. Where does the Bible tell us to wait for the Holy Spirit gift and then be saved?
I’m going to say that the gospel message is not that we should wait, hoping that the Holy Spirit gift may come upon us nor that we should try to reach a state of perfection in order to obtain the Holy Spirit gift. We are to search the Scriptures, repent of our sins, be baptised and live our lives to God. Sorry, I’m not trying to say that God hasn’t chosen His saints. Ephesians 1:4-5. However the gospel message is contained in the Bible and I believe we have the choice to accept it.
I take it you agree that the Lord Jesus led a perfect life according to the law which is how I see it. Jesus fulfilled the law and the prophets. He was the perfect sacrifice. He fulfilled prophecies about himself. He kept the law perfectly showing that it is possible and fulfilling all the law perfectly. 1 Corinthians 15:57 Galatians 3:26-29 I see it that we can be baptised into his victory. Even if all hasn’t been fulfilled, I say that everyone should keep all the commandments directed to them.
‘You are no longer under a guardian’. - “WAS our schoolmaster” is what it says in Galatians 3.
I do not disregard any of the Old Testament. I use a daily reading planner -http://www.dailyreadings.org.uk/- which has two Old Testament readings a day. We should use the Old Testament to teach us about God and so how to live our lives. I believe however that I am not under the law.
We are to keep all the commandments that we are commanded to keep. Also 1 John2:1
Thank you
Hey,
I was trying to find out what you believe the reason for water baptism to be. It is clear that there are many examples of being baptised in water in the New Testament but your view makes these seemingly to have no point.
I don’t see where the Bible says that we need to be baptised in the Holy Spirit to be saved.
In regards to Matthew 3:11. I think that John is speaking to the disciples who were baptised in the Holy Spirit at Pentecost. (You could also note that it seems to me that some of the disciples of the Lord Jesus were previously disciples of John.) If you see Acts 1:5 Jesus is talking to the disciples and links back to Mathew 3:11. Then at the beginning of Acts 2 they are baptised with the Holy Spirit and fire as they had been told. Have you seen tongues of fire come down and rest on you or anyone else in keeping with Matthew 3:11 and Acts 2?
In Ephesians 4:5 I believe that the one baptism is been baptised into the Lord Jesus, which we should do to be saved.
In Mark 16:16 – “He that believeth AND is saved”, I see it that belief is not enough to be saved. You also need to be baptised into the Lord Jesus.
2 Timothy 3: 15-16 …and how from childhood you have been acquainted with the sacred writings, which are able to make you WISE FOR SALVATION through faith in Christ Jesus. 16All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for TRAINING IN RIGHTEOSNESS
2 Peter 1:21 For no prophecy was ever produced by the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.
I believe that we don’t need to have the Holy Spirit gift to be saved, and I don’t see where the Bible says that we do. We have the Bible from God, written by men carried along by the Holy Spirit.
This is how I see it, in the Old Testament there were prophets inspired by the Holy Spirit to teach God’s word so that everyone didn’t need to be inspired. In the New Testament some men and maybe some women (e.g. Philips daughters) had the Holy Spirit for organising and guiding (revealing God’s word to) the believers in the establishment of the faith until that which is perfect/complete is come, i.e. the complete Bible.
1 Corinthians 13:8-12 There are no new prophecies and there is no speaking in tongues now. I think verse 10 is saying the Holy Spirit gifts were to go when the faith was established and the Bible complete. Compare verse 11 to Ephesians 4:13-14. I think that Paul is saying that the gifts are to be no longer around in our time. In Ephesians 4:11-16 – There are no apostles now alive. The unity of the faith and knowledge are in the Bible.
I was not saying that you need to have your conscious marred to think your perfect but I was asking where the Bible says that salvation comes through perfection achieved by having the Holy Spirit gift.
If you then believe that salvation doesn’t require you to live a perfect sinless life but that when you see something is wrong, to steer clear, then we agree. Except maybe you believe that when you realise a sin you will instantly stop committing that sin for good, whereas I do not have so much confidence in myself.
I’m still confused as to how you believe that someone gets the Holy Spirit gift as you agree that Paul wasn’t perfect although he had the gift.
Just to point out the bottom of your reply seems to be missing.
Sorry, I’m just trying to help you to understand the Bible as to me you seem to have some incorrect views. I am also grateful for my beliefs been challenged as it’s good to always consider our beliefs and be able to back them up.
Thank you
Hey, I’ve got to get an assignment done for uni but just a few points:
I believe the Bible tells us all that it needs, why shouldn’t it when early Israel had what they needed without all having Spirit gifts?
You said:
“You ask: “Where does the Bible tell us to wait for the Holy Spirit gift and then be saved?” I have already answered this. If you are not baptized with the Spirit, then you cannot be saved. The words of Jesus. The O.t. They that wait upon the Lord, shall renew their strength. The disciples waited for the Spirit to come to them. Just add those verses together.”
I get that your referring to Isaiah 40:31 but not sure what other verse? That doesn't answer my question either. I am waiting upon the Lord. That doesn’t mean that I will get the Holy Spirit gift prior to the Lord Jesus’ return or that I need to. Waiting upon the Lord is not waiting to be baptised in the Holy Spirit.
If someone has the Holy Spirit gift then surely they’d know for certain, if not what is the difference between them and someone else? You try and separate yourself from churches out there but you have the popular belief of possessing the Holy Spirit.
I gave you a link to an article to show the sort of way in which we are to live our lives because you were asking. There’s no need to make it into any more than that.
It seems to me that you’ve said some things thinking that Christadelphians are like either a typical church or your experience of churches. Christadelphians – The name means Brethren in Christ and came about in order to allow conscientious objection – are Bible believing people who strive for the teaching of the Bible, like the apostles teaching rather that church teaching. We do not have ‘church leaders’.
You’ve given 3 replies since my last one and this is a part response to mainly the first one.
Thanks
Also, I'm not judging you, I'm just trying to point out your misconceptions and guide you.
Hi!
I could not say that Jesus is Lord except that God had revealed it to me, this is done by His spirit. Job 26:13 “By His spirit He has garnished the heavens.” 2 Peter 1:21 God’s word, the Bible, came by the Holy Spirit and God guides His people. This does not mean that I am lead from within. To decide something important I should not think, “This feels right” or “I think that…” rather I should be saying this is what God's word says. Jeremiah 17:9 “The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?” I believe I should base my life on God’s teaching in the Bible rather than basing some things, thinking that this has been revealed to me from a spirit within.
Different people had different spirit gifts but I don’t know of anyone with any powerful spirit gifts now. No healing, speaking in tongues, …
Galatians 3:23 is past tense there is the new way of faith now.
You’ve already agreed that we don’t have to keep the Sabbath.
You agree then that Matthew 3:11 has been fulfilled as no one is now baptised in fire? As people were baptised they didn’t immediately receive the Holy Spirit gift – Acts 8
You posted trying to say I’m wrong about 1 Corinthians 13 because of what it says about knowledge. What is this knowledge? For your interpretation this knowledge needs to fit in with knowledge vanishing away at the Lord Jesus’ return. If you look at the previous chapter, verse 8 fits in with the interpretation I gave and explains it. One is given wisdom as a spirit gift whereas one is given knowledge, so they are not all given this knowledge and it is this gift which has passed away. Seeing face to face can be another metaphor like children growing up showing that the partial is to be replaced with the perfect (complete). If this interpretation is wrong please tell me in another way. I can also understand a greater fulfilment to this when Jesus returns.
When Paul wrote that he knew in part the Bible was not complete.
If you believe that isolation is the only way forward please look at Hebrews 10:25, believers should be meeting with fellow believers.
I believe God’s word above what any man might say and pray for understanding.
I’m trying to do God’s will always but look forward to the time of God’s kingdom when all will worship Him perfectly. I know that I can never be saved through my own perfection but thank God for His mercy and His salvation.
Thank you
Hi,
I was using the verse in Job just to show how the idea of God's spirit is used there.
This is pasted from what you said regarding the Sabbath, "As for the Sabbath, it is blessing from God, and I wouldn't give it up for the world. I know I don't have to keep it, but I enjoy doing so."
As for following your conscience, you cannot use that as an excuse for doing what you think is best. We need to do God's will, this is shown in the Bible. Our beliefs and how we live our lives need to be based on God's word.
You seem to have said before that the only reason that the Lord Jesus overcame and never sinned unlike us is that he had the Holy Spirit from birth.
Anyone could have been sent into the world as 'a robot' without the ability to sin. Sinning is our failing and Jesus' victory over sin shows this.
What about the temptations?
Do not deny the Lord Jesus' victory, his whole life sinless, completely overcoming temptation, the effort, the work, all that he gave
please consider this
Thank you
Hey
1 Corinthians 4:1-4 You recognize we are not naturally good, we learn what's right and what's wrong from God's word. What the Bible tells us is right is different to what the world tells us. We need to study God's word to see His will. We are not to deceive ourselves into following our opinions. 2 Timothy 2:15
You said, "Having the Holy Spirit, which Jesus had from birth, does not mean that one cannot be tempted or fall into sin. It simply means that you now have the power not to sin if you choose to use that power."
So your saying that people aren't born with the power to not sin so it's not their fault if they sin?
In your last paragraph, it seems to me like your saying that God's saints have a higher victory than the Lord Jesus? That is not right.
Thanks
In response to the message before last that you sent:
In 2 Peter 1:21 it says 'no prophecy', not 'no spoken prophecy' also the Bible does contain spoken prophecies, also there's the previous verse.
John 16:12-13 was written before the completed Bible. Same with 2 and 3John.
I say there's now no healing through men with the Holy Spirit that I know of.
About Galatians 3:23 what about verse 24, Christ has come?
Do you believe there are still apostles and prophets? Ephesians 4:11
Thank you
Hi,
We must do God's will so we are to find out what we need to do and do it. If we don't know what to do, we should look at God's word and see how to behave/act. What feels right to us or a feeling within may be in conflict with the Bible in which case it is wrong. (Consciences should be clean)
I'm not saying that 1 Corinthians 4:1-4 is saying we are not to make judgments of right and wrong ways in which we can act. We need to learn how to make these judgments according to the Bible not from what we might feel is right or guidance felt from within.
I thought you believed that everyone receives the Holy Spirit at some point in their lives not that they can call for it in a time of need, I'm a bit confused.
It sounds to me like your saying that the Lord Jesus was given the Holy Spirit from birth so that it was easy/easier for him to overcome whereas we are thrown in at the deep end, and that's not right.
For John 14:12 I put forward Acts 5:12-15
We can read the complete new testament and I believe that with the old testament we've been given all we need from that, as the Bible is from God.
I think faith comes before keeping commandments, that's why you keep them. This seems to agree with the order in Peter - 2 Peter 1:5
What about 1 Corinthians 15:8 as you think there's still apostles now? Do you believe the Bible could still be added to as I guess you may believe there are still new prophecies even this close to the second coming of Christ?
Thank you
Hi
I don't think you should be baptized against your conscience. I think that if you study baptism in the Bible and see the importance of 'water baptism' then you can be baptized in good conscience.
Unfortunately your looking at the Bible with the idea, that so many churches out there have, that you have or will have the Holy Spirit to guide you to truth. This is dangerous as all our views should come solely from God's word. We need to seek the truth.
I don't see where you get your belief from that the Holy Spirit will come to everyone at some point in their life.
We are born with a sinful nature but so was the Lord Jesus as we know he was tempted. I don't believe that Jesus had any advantage over us and from that begin to understand what a wonderful victory his life was and how our sin is our fault that Jesus shows we could/can do better.
Jesus did many miracles and since his ascension many more were done fulfilling John 14:12
Looking at 1 Corinthians 15 it seems to me that those called apostles are those specifically sent by Jesus. Maybe there will be more prophesying but I don't know of any now and we have all we need.
Thanks
Hi
I believe the spirit does guide us. Not as a force within us causing us to know right but the word of God came through His spirit. God's word can guide us to be more spiritual and walk in the correct spirit.
God searches the heart and mind so He can guide people to His truth knowing who they are. If people were left out it still wouldn't be injustice as God gives us far more than we deserve.
I agree that God doesn't need to rely on anyone.
Jesus was the son of man and the son of God. He was tempted just like us but overcame showing forth his Father's characteristics.
We know many miracles were done after the outpouring of the Holy Spirit (Acts 5:12-16) which fulfills John 14:12. We can read of miracles Jesus had done and other miracles. Looking at the context of John 14:12 this makes sense.
Thanks
Hi
I was pointing out that it wouldn't be injustice for people to be 'left out' not saying that that is how it is.
There is no need for us to read about a specific miracle so it does not prove any incompleteness of the Bible.
Thank you
Hi,
Hope your well. This website has an article a week showing the nearness of the Lord Jesus Christ's return as it shows how the news is in line with prophecy. It's good for keeping watch as we await the king's return
http://www.bibleinthenews.com/home/
hope you like it
Luke
http://www.christadelphia.org/books/spirit/index.h
Detailed book on the spirit, please check it out












SirDent Level 4 Commenter 3 years ago
Very well written hub. It gets to the core of the matter. One thing I must point out if it's OK with you. Different denominations have different doctrines mostly due to lack of understanding. It doesn't mean they're unsaved, it just means they need more understanding of God's Word.
Thank you for an enlightening hub.